Guitar Pick Test – Finding the ultimate pick

I used every pick available. The ones available at music shops and those popular with my friends.

I tried wood picks. They had great tones, but they were too noisy. Also, they were worn out fast. Since they were kind of pricey, I gave up on them quickly.

Whatever I was trying, I always got back to the regular pick we find at music shops. 

Recently, I was using Alice’s picks. I bought two boxes of them, and I thought they were OK. 

>>> Guitar Picks <<<

Like many guitar players, I never really paid attention to my right-hand technic until recently. When I was having trouble playing a tricky part, I always focused on my left hand, assuming the error was coming from that side. Most of the time, if not always, the issue was my right hand. Finally, I decided to solve this problem for good. 

My position was wrong. I had known this for a long time, but since I’ve always been able to play fast without practicing much, I thought it was OK. Until a few weeks ago, I played with my fingers resting on the guitar body and with a regular large pick, 1.5mm thick.

But with that position, I was not clean in the bass strings and on certain string jumps. 

So, I ordered many picks from different brands and different thicknesses to find the best fit and improve my right-hand technique. 

>>> Guitar Picks <<<

Here are the picks on the test:

• Ernie Ball Prodigy 2.0mm White Mini.
• Ernie Ball Prodigy 1.5mm Standard.
• Ibanez – JTC 1
• Jim Dunlop John Petrucci signature Ultex 1.5mm
• Jim Dunlop John Petrucci Flow 2.0 mm 

Watch the video

>>> Guitar Picks <<<

I test them in lead mode with crunch sound and rhythm mode with clean sound. When you are testing new picks, first, they are all uncomfortable to play.  You have to get used to them and adapt your hand position to each pick.

Since I’m testing those picks for a week now, I have more ease with the Jim Dunlop John Petrucci Flow 2.0 mm that I elected as my favorite pick than the others I do not fund. 

But if for whatever reason, I decided to use any other pick, I’m sure I will adapt fast. 

my ranking from worst to best is:

• Ernie Ball Prodigy 2.0mm White Mini: way too small I can’t hold it. I feel too uncomfortable. 
• Ibanez – JTC 1. Plastic is too weird—the pick slips. I don’t like the feeling.
•  Ernie Ball Prodigy Standard 1.5mm. I don’t like the angles on the side of the pick. 
• Jim Dunlop John Petrucci signature Ultex 1.5mm. Average. Even if I could get used to it, I prefer to use a regular 1.5 Alice pick than this one. 
• Jim Dunlop John Petrucci Flow 2.0 mm. It is by far my favorite. I love the sound, the ease of playing fast, and the grip.  

I’m still fond of my regular light gauge Alice pick for funky rhythm and acoustic strumming. 

Even if I can funk with my Jim Dunlop Flow 2.0 mm, I prefer the light pick for that.

>>> Guitar Picks <<<

Order the picks reviewed

• Dunlop Ultex Jazz III John Petrucci
• Ernie Ball Prodigy Picks 1,5 mm STD BK
• Ernie Ball Prodigy Picks 2 mm STD WH
• Ibanez PJTC1 Pick Set
• Dunlop John Petrucci Flow Picks

Picks @ Aliexpress

• Guitar Picks

Author Profile

Hervé Senni

 | Site Web

I am Hervé Senni, a pro musician and performer, Composer and arranger for quite some time. My main musical instrument is the electric guitar. I am also a bass player, mandolin, Ukulele player. I also invented string instruments.

Over the years, repairing and improving electric guitars that did not have to be upgraded converted me into a self-taught luthier.

Read More

Related Entries

• Building the Stratocoustic Partcaster: A Fusion of GFS Parts and Graph Tech Acousti-Phonic
• Listen to Tony Iommi's Pickups on My Custom Les Paul Junior Double Cutaway
• My Custom Semi-Hollow Body Stratocaster
• Custom Baritone Guitar with Fanned Frets, Artec H.B.L.C. Hot Rail Humbucker, and Spin-a-Split Wiring

This post is also available in: French